By Miranda Paul
You think you've got it:
The final, polished draft of your picture book.
HAPPY! HAPPY! JOY! JOY!
You revel in post-draft glory (is that a choir of angels singing?) and get a surge of energy to fold those neglected loads of laundry.
Of course, nothing pulls you back to reality like laundry.
The joy fades with each towel you fold. Now you wonder—is your manuscript really finished? Better check on that.
You send off the story to your critique group, a professional editor, or anyone who'll give comments. (Never mind that the only comment you really want to hear is, "This rocks!")
After waiting FOREVER (which is really only days or weeks), all the feedback comes in.
That's when it hits you like a steam puff from the dryer vent:
Reading multiple critiques is as frustrating as folding the sock load.
How is it possible to have so many mis-matches?
You boil one person's comments down to, "Loved the ending, hated the rest." The next critiquer basically says, "Hated the ending, loved the rest." Another person writes, "The middle part lags." And yet, someone else's main concern regards the supporting character's left ear. (What the...??)
Enter the critique conundrum. Suddenly, you question everything about your manuscript. You wonder which direction is the RIGHT direction for your story, or if it's salvageable at all. You're conflicted. Inside, you get defensive. You chalk it up to subjectivity, or wish you'd never shown it to anyone.
What do you do now?
1) Stop panicking.
Remember that you put yourself in this position by sending it out into the world. The more people you send it to, the more likely you'll get at least two opposing suggestions. Expect this, because it's what can happen when you submit to agents and editors. Not everyone is going to agree. Keep calm and write on.
2) Don't "boil down comments" into your own interpretation.
If you aren't sure what a critiquer meant (especially about that random left ear thing), ask him or her to clarify. Ask why they think a certain suggestion is a stronger choice. Don't add your own spin on others' words. Understanding why a critiquer felt a certain way might shed new light on the comments. Above all, do more listening than responding.
3) Find the common thread in opposing comments.
Recently, I had someone tell me to make my animal characters behave more realistically, and another person said to make them more ridiculous/hilarious/un-animal like. Each critiquer gave opposing suggestions, but they were about the same aspect of the book. These two opposing critiques were actually pointing me to the same focus elements for revision: character development and setting up the rules of the animal/human world. Finding the commonality rather than focusing on which suggestion is right or wrong will often illuminate other options for revision.
4) Do separate, focused rounds of revision.
Especially if you've gotten multiple critiques, it's often helpful to set a goal before a revision. If your focus is word count, print out the manuscript and only allow yourself to cut words. If your focus is on character, avoid making plot changes during that revision session. Sometimes, it even helps to open up a blank document and retype the picture book from memory—you'll see what is/was most important to you.
5) Remember that it's OK to disagree with or ignore feedback, and trust yourself.
This is your story. If you have a clear vision, or "heart" to your manuscript, and a particular suggestion takes it into a direction you don't want to explore (or already have, and didn't like), trust your gut. The third book I sold never went out to my critique group, and it sold on the first submission. Remember that your job is not to please everyone, especially adults. If you've got good reason, it's OK to break the rules. In fact, it's more than OK. Quite often, it's award-winning.
6) Be mindful of when and how you send out your work for critique, and to whom you send it.
Before you hit send next time—to a critique partner or anyone—remember that you only get that person's "fresh eyes" once. While critique partners can be very helpful, too many can be harmful. Send your manuscript to writers you trust to be honest and constructive, especially those who are currently published in your genre. Make sure you're submitting something polished and worthy of their time, and let your critiquers know what kind of feedback you are (or aren't) looking for.
Now, if you'll excuse me, I've got laundry to do.
Miranda Paul believes that "A true writer is not measured by the length of her manuscript, but by the depth of her laundry heap." She is the author of One Plastic Bag: Isatou Ceesay and the Recycling Women of The Gambia (Millbrook, Feb. 2015), Water is Water (Neal Porter Books, 2015), 10 Little Ninjas (Knopf Children's/Random House, 2016) and Helping Hands (Millbrook, 2016). In addition to being an instructor for the Children's Book Academy’s course on grammar, she is the founder and administrator of RateYourStory.org, an online service dedicated to helping writers prepare their manuscripts for submission. Follow her on Twitter (@Miranda_Paul) or visit her website at www.MirandaPaul.com.
Meet the Wednesday Blogateers
First Wednesdays will feature Orel Protopopescu, multi-published award -winning author and poet.
Follow our Blogs!
Join our Tribe
and receive 7 Steps to Creative Happiness, access to free webinars, and lots more!
Your email addresses are always safe and respected with us.